Understanding the p-Value: A Guide for Statisticians

Summary:

This blog explains the role of p-values in statistical analysis, highlighting their significance in testing hypotheses and understanding evidence against the null hypothesis. It also emphasizes the need to consider sample size and effect size when interpreting p-values, cautioning against arbitrary significance thresholds.

Reading Time: Approximately 7–10 minutes.

When we test something in science, we start with a basic assumption called the null hypothesis (H₀)—it usually says "nothing is happening" or "there's no effect."

Then, we collect data and calculate a number (called a test statistic) to see how unusual our data is compared to what we'd expect if the null hypothesis were true.

The p-value tells us the chance of getting a result as surprising (or even more surprising) than what we observed, assuming the null hypothesis is true.

A small p-value (like less than 0.05) means our result is really surprising, so we might reject the null hypothesis and think, "Something is probably happening!"
A large p-value means our result isn’t very surprising, so we stick with the null hypothesis.

The p-value helps scientists decide whether their results are meaningful or just random chance!

Example in Agriculture: Testing a New Fertilizer

Let’s make this clearer with an agricultural example:

Imagine a researcher wants to test whether a new fertilizer increases wheat yield compared to no fertilizer. They grow wheat in ten plots of land five for each case:

Group A: No fertilizer (control group)
Group B: New fertilizer (treatment group)

After the growing season, they measure the average wheat yield.

Step-by-step:

Start with the null hypothesis (H₀):
The new fertilizer has no effect on wheat yield (the yields in Group A and Group B are the same).
Collect data:
- Group A (no fertilizer) average yields 4 tons per acre.
- Group B (new fertilizer) average yields 5 tons per acre.
Calculate the p-value:
The p-value answers this question:
“If the fertilizer really has no effect, how likely is it to see a difference of 1 ton (or more) between the two plots just by random chance?”
Using statistical software (two sample t test), the researcher calculates the p-value to be 0.02 (2%).
Interpret the p-value:
- A p-value of 0.02 means there’s only a 2% chance of getting a difference this large (or larger) if the fertilizer truly doesn’t work.
- Since the p-value is small (less than 0.05), the researcher rejects the null hypothesis and concludes that the fertilizer likely increases wheat yield.

What Does a P-value Really Mean?

The p-value is a number between 0 and 1 that gives us a measure of how strong the evidence is against the null hypothesis (H₀). For example, a p-value of 0.076 means there’s about a 7.6% chance of observing a result as extreme as the one we got, or more extreme, if the null hypothesis is true.

It’s important to understand that a p-value is not the probability that the alternative hypothesis (H₁) is true. Instead, it tells us how likely it is to see extreme results under the assumption that the null hypothesis is correct.

Here are some general guidelines for interpreting p-values:

p < 0.001: Very strong evidence against H₀.
p < 0.01: Strong evidence against H₀.
p < 0.05: Moderate evidence against H₀.
p < 0.1: Weak evidence or a trend.
p ≥ 0.1: Insufficient evidence to reject H₀.

However, these cutoffs are not set in stone. Declaring results as simply “significant” or “not significant” based on a fixed threshold (like 0.05) can be misleading. As Ronald Fisher, a pioneer in statistics, once said:

“No scientific worker has a fixed level of significance at which, from year to year, and in all circumstances he rejects hypotheses; he rather gives his mind to each particular case in the light of his evidence and his ideas.”

Important Points About P-values

A p-value doesn’t provide evidence in support of the null hypothesis.
A large p-value doesn’t mean the null hypothesis is true; it just means there isn’t enough evidence to reject it. Be careful not to “accept” the null hypothesis based on a large p-value.
A small p-value doesn’t prove the alternative hypothesis is true.
It just tells us that rejecting the null hypothesis is reasonable based on the data.
P-values depend on sample size.
- With a very large sample size, even very small differences can lead to tiny p-values, making it easy to reject H₀.
- With a very small sample size, even large differences may result in large p-values, making it hard to reject H₀.
Consider the size of the effect.
A statistically significant result (small p-value) doesn’t always mean the result is practically important. Small p-values can come from:
- A small effect in a very large sample.
- A large effect in a very small sample.

To get a complete picture, combine the p-value with the size of the effect and its confidence interval. This will help you understand both the statistical and practical significance of your results.

Key Takeaway

The p-value is a helpful tool in statistical analysis, but it must be used carefully. It’s not a magic number that decides everything, and it should always be interpreted alongside other information like sample size, effect size, and confidence intervals. In agriculture, where sample sizes and variability can vary greatly, understanding the full context of the data is essential for drawing meaningful conclusions.

This blog is written by Dr Raj Popat Data Scientist, Syngenta Seed, Hyderabad, India

Search This Blog

Agricultural Statistics